The Catholic Church’s Moral Failure and the Greek Orthodox Church’s Lessons for Humanity During WWII

5

I visited Yad Vashem recently— the Holocaust Museum in Jerusalem which memorializes the 6 million lost souls during the Holocaust, but also pays tribute to those non-Jews, primarily Christians throughout Europe, who risked their own lives to save their Jewish compatriots.

The trip was for research for a short film that the Greek America Foundation is producing called No Man is an Island, about the survival of the Jewish community of Zakynthos during the dark years of the Holocaust.

This museum of death and hatred— filled with constant reminders of man’s cruelty to fellow man— is smartly surrounded by a beautiful garden of trees, each one planted in memory of a “righteous among the nations” person who played his or her part in saving Jews when they were being hunted like would animals.

While perusing the displays, I came across a panel dedicated to the Vatican’s role during the Holocaust and was dumfounded to read that the then Pope of the Catholic Church and spiritual leader of billions of the world’s Catholics was a coward, failing to do what his own faith and dedication to his God called for during one of the darkest moments in human history.

It was a part of human history when institutions with a moral and ethical charge, like Churches, supposedly founded on lessons of love and humanity, were supposed to be leaders for their faithful and set examples.

Pope Pius, I read (and later researched) remained silent, claiming neutrality. I was shocked to learn that he even signed a pact with the Nazis to “protect” Germany’s Catholics. He even refused to sign an Allied protest of December 17, 1942 condemning the extermination of the Jews.

The Vatican knew very well what was going on. And what’s worse is that amid the dark knowledge of what was happening, there were numerous cries for help.

The Cardinal of Vienna repeatedly told Pius about the Jewish deportations. In 1942, the Slovakian charge d’affaires reported to Rome that Slovakian Jews were being systematically deported and sent to death camps. The Assistant Chief of the U.S. delegation to the Vatican, Harold Tittman, asked the Pope to condemn the atrocities, as well. The response came that the Holy See wanted to remain “neutral,” and that condemning the atrocities would have a negative impact on Catholics in German-held lands.

In late August 1942, after more than 200,000 Ukrainian Jews had been killed, The Greek Catholic Ukrainian Metropolitan, a Church under Rome, wrote a long letter to the Pope, seeking his intervention.

The Pope replied by quoting verses from Psalms and advising hierarch to “bear adversity with serene patience.” People just witnessed the brutal deportation of 200,000 of their fellow humans and the Pope advises calm and serene patience.

In 1942, Myron Taylor, U.S. representative to the Vatican, warned the Pope that his silence was endangering his moral authority.

Now, let’s move a tad to the right on the world map— to Greece, where the story of the Church and the Holocaust is startlingly different, where the “organized church” from the top down, played a significant role in saving as many Jews as possible during these tragic times.

Yes, the fact remains that Greece lost upwards of 90% of its ancient Jewish community that predated Alexander the Great, but that wasn’t because people didn’t try— especially the organized church.

The truth is that I haven’t been to church in a long time and this post isn’t motivated by some secret agenda to prove that Greek Orthodox Christians are in some way morally superior, or that one Church is better than the other.

I don’t know enough about church politics, theology or even canonical differences to know the disparity between the world’s two largest Christian churches— the Roman Catholic and the Orthodox Christian.

It was the visit to Yad Vashem and the knowledge I obtained about Pope Pius, and the knowledge I had about the exact opposite response the Church in Greece had during the Holocaust.

DAMASKINOS, the Archbishop of Athens and all Greece
“
I have made my cross, have spoken with God, and decided to save as many Jews.”

Take for instance the leadership role of the high-profile head, the Archbishop of Athens and All Greece, Damaskinos, took. Not hiding behind cowardly “neutrality” of his counterpart in Rome, Damaskinos openly and unabashedly opposed the deportation of the Jews of Greece and took drastic, and sometimes life-threatening measures to fulfill his mission.

With the support of the police chief of Athens, Archbishop Damaskinos oversaw the creation of several thousand “baptismal certificates”, and provided more than 27,000 false identify papers to desperate Jews seeking protection from the Nazis. The forged papers gave them Christian names and allowed them free passage through Nazi checkpoints. The Archbishop also ordered monasteries and convents in Athens to shelter Jews, and urged his priests to ask their congregations to hide the Jews in their homes. As a result, more than 250 Jewish children were hidden by Orthodox clergy alone.

Damaskinos also spearheaded a direct appeal to the Germans, in the form of a letter in a bold defense of the Jews who were being persecuted.

The letter incited the rage of the ferocious Nazi General Jürgen Stroop— the man responsible for the brutal suppression of the Warsaw Ghetto uprising and the loss of 50,000 lives who had since been transferred to Greece. He threatened the Archbishop with death by a firing squad.

Damaskinos’ response was, ”Greek religious leaders are not shot, they are hanged. I request that you respect this custom.” The simple courage of the religious leader’s reply caught the Nazi commander off guard.

The appeal of the Archbishop and his fellow Greeks is unique; there is no similar document of protest of the Nazis during World War II that has come to light in any other European country. It reads, in part:

”In our national consciousness, all the children of Mother Greece are an inseparable unity: they are equal members of the national body irrespective of religion… Our holy religion does not recognize superior or inferior qualities based on race or religion, as it is stated: ‘There is neither Jew nor Greek’ and thus condemns any attempt to discriminate or create racial or religious differences. Our common fate both in days of glory and in periods of national misfortune forged inseparable bonds between all Greek citizens, without exemption, irrespective of race…”

”Today we are… deeply concerned with the fate of 60,000 of our fellow citizens who are Jews… we have lived together in both slavery and freedom, and we have come to appreciate their feelings, their brotherly attitude, their economic activity, and most important, their indefectible patriotism…”

JOACHIM, the Metropolitan Bishop of Volos
“I am a Jew”
 Joachim, the Greek Orthodox Bishop of Volos when asked for the names of Jews in his region

On September 30, 1943, the Jewish New Year, the chief rabbi of the central Greek city of Volos was ordered to report to the German military leader, Kurt Rikert, and submit a list of the names of the city’s Jewish community within 24 hours. At the time, there were 872 Jewish residents.

The rabbi turned to his friend, Metropolitan (Archbishop) Joachim (Alexopoulos) who presided over the Greek Orthodox flock of the region and didn’t even blink an eye when asked to help.

He ordered every priest in his diocese to help any Jew who asked for it and signed his own name to a letter of introduction that the rabbi used to seek hiding. The letter read in part “I heartily recommend the teacher, bearer of this letter, and I ask every brother who is going to meet him, to listen to him carefully and in good will, and to give him any kind of assistance for anything he may be in need of for his life as well as for his flock, so they do not become victims of this difficult situation.”

Joachim mobilized the underground of the region and within 24 hours, 702 Greek Jews fled and were taken into the protective hands of strangers in the villages of the mountains surrounding the city. When he was asked for information about Jews from the Germans he firmly refused their requests for lists of Jewish residents, answering them, “I am a Jew”.

The 130 Jews who decided to remain behind were arrested by the SS and sent to Auschwitz. The Nazis blew up the synagogue and looted and pillaged the shops and homes in the Jewish neighborhood.

In November 1944 after the liberation of Greece and the Jews came out of hiding, Joachim issues a statement urging all local inhabitants to return to the Jewish residents any valuables they may have either taken during the looting or left in their hands for safe-keeping.
For saving the lives of some 700 people, he was recognized posthumously, in 1998, by the State of Israel with an inscription in the Holocaust Museum in Washington, D.C. and on the Righteous Honor Wall at Yad Vashem in Jerusalem.

CHRYSOSTOMOS, the Metropolitan Bishop of Zakynthos

”I will march together with the Jews straight into the gas chamber.”

Of course, there is also the timeless survival story of the ONLY Jewish community in all of Europe that didn’t lose a single soul during the Holocaust, on the Greek Island of Zakynthos— thanks to the efforts of the Metropolitan Bishop of the island, Chrysostomos.

When asked for the island’s Jews, he offered his own name, and that of the Mayor’s, as the island’s Jews and proceeded to tell the German commandant that he was prepared to march with his Jewish neighbors straight to the gas chambers if that were his destiny.
“The Jews of Zakynthos are Greeks, peace-loving and industrious. They are pure-blooded Zakynthians and totally harmless. I beg you to rescind the criminal order.”

When the commander remained persistent and threatened Chrysostomos and the mayor with their lives, and severe reprisals against the civilian population of the island, they handed him a scrap of paper with their own two names scribbled on it.

“I am at your mercy,” Chrysostomos told the Nazi. “You can arrest me, not them. If this does not satisfy you, then know that I will march together with the Jews straight into the gas chamber.”

In conclusion— three Greek Orthodox hierarchs, each with high-profile positions of moral authority, spoke to their God and responded with what they believed to be their moral and ethical responsibility.

Unfortunately, the Pope of the Catholic Church hid behind a cowardly neutrality and the result— who knows what the result could have been had the head of the largest Christian church in the world had defied modern humanity’s darkest hour and had rather stood as a beacon of light and goodness— as did his counterparts in Greece.

Long live the memory of Chrysostomos, Damaskinos, Joachim— and all of the Greek Orthodox hierarchs and clergy who did their part for their faith, and for humanity. Although I don’t speak to him personally, I think their actions would have made Jesus Christ proud.

Share.

5 Comments

  1. ????? MANS IN-HUMANITY TO HIMSELF……..HAS IT CHANGED > THE NAZIS USED THE MUSLIMS TO ENFORCE THERE EXTERMINATION WAR AGAINST THE JEWISH AND ANY OTHER THREAT THEY FELT WORTHY OF THEIR DECEMINATION, GYPSIES, POLE'S, RUSSIANS,……… AND TODAY GERMANY DICTATES AND RUNS THE E/U..( AND ARE FINANCIALLY ENTRENCHED IN THE MUSLIM AND FACISTA COMMUNITY- TURKEY-ARGENTINA – THEIR PRIVATE MONEY PIT'S)……. THEIR EVIL / STILL RULE'S SUPREME.!.AND WOULD YOU BELIEVE THAT THERE IS A MAJOR IMMIGRATION OF JEWS BACK TO GERMANY ?…..I GUESS GREEEEEEEED STILL RULES THE MORALITY OF THE WORLD………………….AND THE IDEA THAT GREECE GAVE THE PROPERTY BACK TO THE JEWS=IS ALL "B/S"………I HAVE FIRST HAND KNOLEDGE ON THAT ONE , AND LAUGHED WHEN I READ THE ARTICLE., GREED AND MONEY AND POSSESIONS RULE ALL RELIGIONS…….SOME PEOPLE LIVE IN VERY DIFFERENT PROTECTED TOWERS THAN THE REST OF US.! > GREECE SHOULD TAKE A GOOD LOOK AT THERE CHURCH AND STATE EXISTANCE BEFORE THEY START THROWING STONES. !………HAVE A GOOD DAY …….

  2. Frances Felter Rouse on

    You clearly did not research the Catholic Church's role during WWII, through a mandate of Pius the 12th, the church in Italy saved over 900,000 Jews. They hid them in the Vatican,churches, monasteries, until they could be moved.

    • Jeremy Wheeler on

      No country emerged from those times with much honour but it is true that a relatively small number of Italian Jews were murdered by the Nazis. The 900,000 you claim were saved is wrong, though. Italy’s Jewish population before the war was around 40,000 and there were around 10.000 further foreign Jews living there. Around 9,000 were deported.

      What saved the Italian Jews was the attitude of the Italian people: to them Jews were Italians first and Jews second. Italian Jews were the most assimilated in Europe and were seen as patriots rather than a foreign body within. Many Jews were saved because of the actions of members of the Italian clergy but that doesn’t alter the facts of Pope Pius’ position with regard to the Nazis.

Leave A Reply